Proceeds vs. gain
Gain or loss is generally the proceeds minus your cost basis (what you paid, plus certain costs and adjustments). If basis is missing or wrong, the full proceeds can be treated as gain — even when your actual profit was much smaller, or you had a loss.
Hypothetical example
You sold investments for $50,000. Your records substantiate a cost basis of $45,000. That may represent a $5,000 gain before other applicable adjustments — rather than $50,000 of gain. Holding period, wash sales, fees and other rules can change the result. Not every IRS bill is wrong, and not every case results in a reduction.
1099-B, 1099-DA and SFR situations are different
Form 1099-B (brokers)
Reports sales of stocks, bonds and similar securities. Basis may be reported to the IRS for some shares and not for others (for example, older or transferred shares). Missing basis is commonly corrected by reporting it on Form 8949 with your records.
Form 1099-DA (digital assets)
A newer broker form for crypto and other digital asset sales. Early versions may report gross proceeds without basis, and assets moved between wallets or exchanges often lack basis on the form. Your own transaction history matters.
SFR (no return filed)
If you didn't file, the IRS may prepare a Substitute for Return from reported proceeds. That is an unfiled-return problem with its own notices and deadlines — see my CP3219N / CP2566 notice help.
Received an unfiled-return notice? Get help with IRS CP3219N or CP2566 notices.
When to seek help
- Missing basis: your 1099-B or 1099-DA shows proceeds but no cost basis, or the basis looks wrong.
- Mismatched broker reporting: transferred assets, multiple exchanges or corrected forms don't line up with what was filed.
- IRS CP2000 notice: the IRS proposes extra tax on unreported sales. Learn about CP2000 help.
- Already assessed balance: the tax has been assessed and you believe basis was never considered.
Deadlines depend on the notice you actually received and the stage of your case — check the date on your letter. A consultation does not stop or extend any IRS deadline. Reconstructing a full transaction history is separate, quoted work.
Official guidance: IRS Instructions for Form 8949
How I can help
- Review your notice and what the IRS has on record — see my IRS transcript and tax account review service.
- Identify which transactions lack basis and what records may support it.
- Explain your options for responding, filing or requesting reconsideration.
General taxpayer education, not individualized tax advice. IRS outcomes are not guaranteed.
